Friday, July 14, 2017

The State of Oil & Gas (A version of this article appeared in the Big Bend Sentinel, 2017)






Smog. A lot of it lately. Almost every time I drive in the Texas Big Bend country I see less blue, less mountain.

By chance I got a call from Texas Sharon of Earthworks. “Wanna go for a drive?” She asked. We head toward Balmorhea in her Dodge with Wilma Subra, a renowned chemist, filmmaker Joe Cashiola and Sharon’s FLIR video camera that makes visible the invisible air pollution coming from oil&gas facilities. We’re looking for leaks. Smog makers. Methane.

The shale play region around Balmorhea State Park, known as the Alpine High, is the most active fossil fuel hunt in the world right now. John Christman, CEO of Apache Corp., pledged to his shareholders last year he’d spend two billion dollars in 2017 exploring there for oil & gas. $2B is a lot of combustion.

Sharon stops the Dodge on the side of Highway 17, 30 miles south of Pecos and focuses the FLIR lens toward an oil well tank battery that seemed benign but in the camera’s black&white monitor we see clouds of gas rise from the tanks. “See that one,” she points. “Not only is it venting through the pipe but the top of the tank is leaking too.”

The Texas Commission on Environmental Quality (TECQ) allows up to 25 tons of Volatile Organic Compounds (VOC’s) to be released from existing sources yearly. This allows harmful gases from hydrocarbon production including ethylacetate, hexane, and 2-butanone to vent into the atmosphere, adding to the Green House Effect, that human induced phenomena that keeps heat trapped in our atmosphere creating global warming. Sharon is sure that most sources in Texas exceed this yearly limit. And that quantity does not even include methane aka natural gas. Unlike Colorado and some other hydrocarbon producing states, methane, in Texas is unregulated. “But the real problem,” she said. “Is they’re not even monitoring. I’ve sent them clips of leaking gas but seldom do they take action.”

The Texas Commission on Environmental Quality production permits allow many other air pollutants such as nitrous oxide to be released which combined with VOC’s and sunlight create the ozone smog we see on the horizon.”

We look toward the Davis Mountains but they are not there.

This year the State of Texas cut the TECQ air pollution budget by $20million per year guaranteeing an even more passive approach to air pollution. Oil&Gas doesn’t seem to like regulation, moreover enforcement. And with Governor Abbott leading this charge, motivated perhaps by half million dollar campaign contributions from the likes of pipeline giant Kelcy Warren – what can we expect, ethical behavior? Or should we rejoice in behavior deemed legal by rich lawyers in office conjuring for their oil&gas buddies?

We drive north and scope another tank battery. All leaking, all venting. Then we check a flare, from a distance - the roar of pressure pushes the base of the flame 20 feet from the top of the flare stack.

“That one relieves pressure directly from the underground formation,” Subra said. The flare next to it black smokes but mildly pyrographic compared to the devil next to it.

We turn down another road and watch through the FLIR camera monitor another set of tanks off-gassing. With the methane comes carcinogens including toluene, benzene, and sulfuric acid. If you’re unfortunate enough to live in the vicinity of oil&gas production, common health effects include respiratory impacts, sinus problems, throat irritation, allergies, fatigue, eye and nasal irritation, breathing difficulties, vision impairment, severe headaches, swollen joints, and sleep disturbances.

We stop now at a frack on a Rosetta Corporation wellhead. Fracks are generally a 3 day operation. Ten million gallons of water are lost to the hydro-logic cycle forever. Five hundred tons of special sand along with blends of various “proprietary” chemicals including diesel, pesticides, detergents, solvents, and carcinogens like benzyl chloride, formaldehyde, and napthalene are mixed into the fracking solutions.

Trucks smoked as they lined up in a snaky half mile queue ready to discharge their goo into the crevices of our earth.

“They’re going to frack tonight Joe,” I whisper in Joe’s ear as if conscience will be struck from all moral codes for the next few hours.

Eight thousand miles away, a New York Times article reports this week, that a laboratory off the Tasmanian coast is monitoring our air, air that should be some of the cleanest on the planet as it sweeps across thousands of miles of ocean.

It appears, however, according to the article by Justin Gillis, that over the last two years atmospheric Carbon Dioxide concentrations, the No.1 source of the Green House Effect, have accelerated. Consequently global warming/climate change, will accelerate, and Mother Nature may become Mother Strange.

The NYT article suggests that the natural sponges, likes trees and oceans have been absorbing much fossil-fuel generated CO2 over the years of the industrial age but are now saturated. And methane, 80 times more powerful as a greenhouse gas than Carbon Dioxide over a twenty year period, flows like no tomorrow in the once pristine area of the Big Bend.


We climb back in the Dodge now. I have a headache. There is less talk. We head back to Marfa, as the mountains, cleft and everlasting, slowly re-emerge through the smog.